What's new
Guest viewing is limited

Andrew Luck or RG3?

RGIII is really a Vick clone.

will_smith_no_gif.gif


RGIII is immeasurably better than Vick was coming out of college.
 
I remember the debate of Leaf vs. Manning. I, like a lot of people thought that Leaf was the better QB. We all know how that turned out. I think Luck is more prepared to start right now.
 
I remember the debate of Leaf vs. Manning. I, like a lot of people thought that Leaf was the better QB. We all know how that turned out. I think Luck is more prepared to start right now.

Yep I do to. I do think RGIII could have a successful rookie campaign though. If his anticipation, his "prediction" of how each play will unfold, really needs to get better though. That's really my only problem with him at the pro level.
 
RGIII is mobile enough that his height shouldn't be that much of an issue, but the bigger problem for me is durability. Luck has a huge frame, decent athletic ability, a great arm, and extremely high football IQ.

It's hard to really say that there is ANY recent QB prospect I'd take over Luck. RGIII may well be a good quarterback, but there isn't really anything you would change about Luck even if you could.

Very good point. I think RGIII would be a surefire #1 pick any other draft though. It's been a while since there have been 2 QBs that could be a good #1 pick.
 
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2012/02/21/14-of-15-nfl-scouts-prefer-luck-to-griffin-iii/

Interesting article about how 14 of 15 NFL scouts prefer RG3. Basically they all agree it's like splitting hairs picking between the two, but RG3's athleticism is something they couldn't pass up.

The more I read about this guy the more amped I get about him. Can't wait to see where he lands on draft day.

Finally got a chance to read the article. You didn't read that, did you? :p That's not what that article says at all, it's the total opposite actually.
 
Definitely haven't had 2 QB's projected to be so good in a long time. I wish the Bills could have had a chance at either one of them, but unfortunately it looks like they are stuck with Fitzpatrick now. He's an ok QB, but not someone that is going to lead you to the Superbowl.
 
Don't really know about the question but RGIII is insanely athletic. He was .01 from breaking the national high school record in the 300 hurdles his junior year of high school, and then graduated high school in December of his senior year and enrolled at Baylor. So what should have been his senior year of high school, he got third at NCAA Nationals in the 400 hurdles. Didn't run track ever since he hurt himself the following year and decided to focus on football. He has put on a lot of football weight but he was definitely on track to be an Olympian in that event.
 
The Colts should take RG3. He has proven more in his career than Luck has and is a much more versatile QB. The Colts need a running game and RG3 can provide that. The Colts will end up taking Luck, but the smart choice is RG3.
 
The Colts should take RG3. He has proven more in his career than Luck has and is a much more versatile QB. The Colts need a running game and RG3 can provide that. The Colts will end up taking Luck, but the smart choice is RG3.

14/15 NFL experts agree that Luck is the smart choice.
 
Back
Top